The Disappearing Manager: When Boundaries Become Avoidance

Over the last few years, workplace leadership has undergone a profound shift. Managers are being asked to be empathetic, trauma-informed, boundary-aware, and supportive of well-being. This is progress. But in that progress, a new pattern is emerging:

The well-meaning leader who disappears.

It doesn’t look dramatic. There’s no memo. No exit.
But little by little, presence fades.

Meetings become less personal.
Feedback gets vague—or disappears altogether.
Support turns into silence.

And it’s not because leaders have stopped caring.
It’s often because they do care—and they’re afraid to get it wrong.

The Fear Beneath the Silence

As a workplace culture strategist and leadership coach, I hear this often:

• “I don’t want to micromanage.”

• “I’m worried I’ll say the wrong thing.”

• “They’re clearly overwhelmed. I don’t want to add pressure.”

And those instincts come from a good place. But without clarity and connection, teams drift. And in trying to protect peace, managers sometimes create confusion, disconnection, or resentment.

Leadership isn’t about control—but it is about presence.

Why Feedback Still Matters

A 2023 Harvard Business Review study found that:

• Employees who receive regular, meaningful feedback are 3x more engaged

• Teams with strong managerial support report 31% higher retention

In other words: Clarity is a form of care.

When leaders stop showing up in real, relational ways, employees fill in the blanks. And often, the stories they create aren’t generous.

My Own Learning Curve

Years ago, I managed someone who was struggling with follow-through. She was brilliant—but inconsistent. I avoided the hard feedback, telling myself she needed space. But deep down, I didn’t want to be “that boss.”

Eventually, she left the role—and she told me later that she wished I had stepped in sooner. That the silence made her feel like she wasn’t worth developing.

That landed hard. Because she was right.

What Can Leaders Do?

We don’t need to choose between boundaries or feedback.
Space or support.
Kindness or accountability.

We need to redefine leadership as:

• Present: Don’t disappear when it’s hard.

• Clear: Set expectations and offer real-time feedback.

• Relational: Acknowledge the whole person—but still lead the team.

The goal isn’t to never offend. The goal is to be honest, human, and invested in growth—yours and theirs.

Final Thoughts

If you’re a leader, ask yourself:

• Where might I be withholding out of fear?

• When was the last time I offered real, clear encouragement or redirection?

• Am I disappearing in the name of respect?

And if you’re an employee, know this: You deserve feedback. You deserve presence. You deserve leaders who show up.

👇 Comment below or subscribe to The Happiness Shift newsletter for more reflections on well-being, leadership, and belonging at work.